Run Commerce wants guests. Apply →
Talk Commerce Talk Commerce
There Is Not Enough Retail in Retail Media with Marc Walkin of QSIC
| 6 min read

There Is Not Enough Retail in Retail Media with Marc Walkin of QSIC


Marc Walkin leads global marketing at QSIC, a company that runs in-store audio and retail media for retailers like 7-Eleven, and he describes his job as raising awareness of the part of retail media that the industry has been sleeping on, which is the store itself. He calls himself “the chief in store ambassador for retail media,” and inside the company he has a second title.

“My nickname in QSIC is Chief Meme Officer,” he says.

He rated the Free Joke Project a ten, the one about the man who walks into a bar carrying a piece of asphalt and orders a beer for himself and one for the road.

Where the Money Goes and Where the Shoppers Are

I asked Marc for the ten thousand foot view of retail media, and he started with reach. Brick and mortar retailers see more of their community on a regular basis than almost any place outside of schools and places of worship, and retailers have figured out that the traffic is an asset they can sell.

“It’s turning those eyeballs into an ad network,” he says.

The asymmetry is the reason QSIC exists. Marc puts the share of retail media ad dollars spent online at ninety nine percent, while 85 to 90 percent of transactions happen in the store.

“Ninety nine percent of ad dollars in retail media are online right now,” he says.

QSIC started as a premium music streaming company for hospitality and quick service restaurants, with music curation and automatic volume control, and when COVID hit the founders asked how retailers could make money from an audio network that was already in the stores.

Energy Drinks at Seven in the Morning

The difference between QSIC and the loop of music and ads that stores have played for years is the data underneath it, and Marc gave me a 7-Eleven example. Point-of-sale data might show a spike in energy drink sales at seven in the morning in five percent of the stores, because those stores sit next to a construction site or on the route for a certain kind of work.

“We will run energy drinks ads at 7 a.m. so when the demand is highest,” he says.

The same data can shift the language of the ads toward Spanish in a cluster of stores with a large Hispanic community, or give the voice a southern accent in Texas, so I asked whether a store in Fargo would get a heavy northern Minnesota accent.

“We could. We could. Yes. I don’t know that we’re quite we’ve gotten there yet, but in theory, yes, we could do that,” he says.

The older model plays a generic playlist, maybe updated for the holidays, with the same six ads over and over in every store, and the retailer does not know who heard them or whether they played.

“So it’s basically dumb audio,” he says.

Five Minutes, Not Three Weeks

Marc came to QSIC from the brand side, CPG and retail rather than ad tech, and the measurement standard in retail media bothers him. The common model gives an ad credit when a shopper sees it on a news site next to eight other ads and buys the product three weeks later.

“Someone’s gonna take credit for someone buying toothpaste that they saw an ad three weeks ago when it was probably on sale in the store is just complete nonsense,” he says.

QSIC ties attribution to dwell time. The average visit at 7-Eleven is six minutes, so the window is five.

“And we only count it as an incremental sale if they buy it within five minutes of hearing the ad,” he says.

He wants the same thinking applied to promotions. If a product is on sale in the store and the measurement ignores it, the incrementality number goes up because of the discount, and he is fine with a lower number once the sale price is counted.

“There’s not enough retail in retail media,” he says.

Why Merchants Push Back

I asked Marc what he meant by retail media working against merchants, and his answer came down to trade dollars. A brand puts something like twenty percent of its net sales back into trade, which pays for the sale prices, the in-store signage and the displays, and merchants get credit for that spend. Retail media pulls dollars away from trade into something the merchants do not get credit for.

Before QSIC, Marc co-founded a company that studied why brands passed on new retail media networks.

“The number two reason why a brand would not engage with a new retail media network is because the merchant at that retailer said don’t do it,” he says.

He sees some convergence, with incentives and joint business plan credit starting to line up, and the core problem stays the same.

“Merchants don’t think retail media tactics drive sales in the same way that trade does,” he says.

A Recalibration Is Coming

I asked whether he expects a correction in retail media, and he has been saying so for a while.

“I’ll call it a recalibration,” he says.

The headline numbers look good, with a forecast he put near eighty billion dollars in the US and growth of twenty percent a year. Take out Amazon, which is seventy five to eighty percent of the category, and take out Walmart Connect, and Marc says what is left is an eight billion dollar industry growing around ten percent, with the long tail of retailers missing their numbers and running out of inventory to sell.

I brought up Target, and Marc chose to be kind.

“Anyway, trying to give them love,” he says.

Where a Mid-Size Retailer Starts

For a regional chain with three hundred stores and a smaller budget than Target, Marc’s advice starts with where the sales are. Those chains do ninety to ninety five percent of their business in the store.

“Why in the world would they not maximize in store?” he says.

He would start with a merchant-driven strategy and shopper marketing, then add audio and screens. The economics are the reason retailers are interested. The average retailer runs an EBITDA of four or five percent.

“The margin for retail media is eighty plus percent depending on the channel mix,” he says.

“For every dollar made in retail media, it’s the equivalent of twenty dollars made you know, selling your cans of soup,” he says.

After that, he expects mid-tier retailers to pool inventory on the back end with other regional retailers who do not compete with them, so the group can sell against the Krogers and the Targets.

The Plug

Marc’s shameless plug went to QSIC, after a quick one for the new Spider-Man movie. QSIC’s platform takes point-of-sale and loyalty data, forecasts the right campaign for each store, and lets a brand change course while a campaign is running, for audio, screens or any other in-store channel.

“You can optimize in real time instead of waiting six weeks to see how it did,” he says.

Find QSIC at getqsic.com and Marc on LinkedIn.

Watch the Episode